Home From The Field Permissions are a privilege, not a right

Permissions are a privilege, not a right

Permissions are a privilege, not a right

Republished with permission from TheDailyWTF:

timbstoke writes:

So we’ve just implemented a new change management process. As part of this, any changes to production systems need to be documented in full, and reviewed by a coworker from the same team and a manager before changes are made. All well and good, makes sense, no complaints. Well….maybe one.

I wanted to make a change to one of our mail appliances. My implementation plan was as detailed as it needed to be for any competent engineer – “back up the config. Change x from y to z. Commit the changes. Repeat on all appliances in the pool.”

I submitted it for review. It got rejected – not enough detail. I queried it.

Boss: It fails at the first step. I don’t know how to back up the config. I also don’t know where to find any of these values that you’re changing.

Me: I’m making the change, and I do know how to back up the config.

Boss: But what if you’re not here?

Me: I am here. I want to make the change right now.

Boss: Granted, but it should be step by step – What if someone needs to roll back your change?

Me: Everyone in the team knows how to back up the config, and where to find the values that are being changed.

Boss: But what if it’s not one of your team? You need to document exactly where to click or what to type, step by step, so anyone could do it.

Me: I don’t want anyone to do it. If it’s not one of my team, they’d better stay the f$#k away from my appliances.

– YES x 1000.  I understand the need for recovery practices/DR/ISO, etc. but the key is getting someone who is familiar with the equipment/processes to be the one following the instructions and recognizing problems when the arise – i.e. knowing when to back off before totally hosing everything. – Rob

via: [TheDailyWTF]

Picture Source: [Jeff Sandquist]


  1. This is the issue with today’s IT, we spend more time writing documentation and taking meetings than getting work done.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.